Stop the madness, please!
In his introductory post on sp.com, simon makes reference to his hometown of Vancouver having played host to one of the best Silverfucks of all time.
It’s a form of a statement that I see far too many times, regarding the glory of the 1/8/97 Mellon Collie show at GM Place. The reality is, there is nothing awe-inducing about the concert. The deification of this show needs to be brought back down to a more respectable level.
First, I get why people do laud the show. Due to the FM broadcast by CBC two months later, it’s the best recording representation fans have of the tail end of the Mellon Collie era. And Billy and co. seem to be in genial moods, as the show is the 4th after a 2-week holiday break and they’re just gearing back up for the final month. On top of that, it is a solid performance with a good crowd.
Now that that’s established, is there anything that makes this show stand out above any of the countless others from the Mellon Collie tour, or even more detailed, the Matt Walker era? Other than that impeccable sound quality?
Sound quality does not equal performance quality, people. And the performance is not legendary in the least.
The run of Southern California shows a month earlier had the band firing on all cylinders, with some of their strongest performances since the restart of the tour. Even the Seattle show from 2 days before is at least as good a performance, with the exact same setlist. Vancouver is good, but it’s entirely Pumpkin paint-by-numbers if you focus on the performance and not the strength of the recording. (more…)