It’s blogger-vs.-blogger today in the, um, blogosphere. In light of his smelly plans to revisit Smashing Pumpkins music from the late 1980s and early 1990s, what does Billy Corgan deserve? Google-indexed random bloggers D.A.N. (of soulofrocknroll.com) and boldensghost (a LiveJournalist!) couldn’t disagree more:
D.A.N.:
I have a ton of respect for Billy Corgan because he seems to really be in it for the love of the music, and for the fans, and that respect continues with the new upcoming releases scheduled for the band… First, there’s a new album planned for the up coming year… Second, they’re putting together a DVD detailing their residency at the Fillmore from this past year… AND if that all wasn’t enough… A planned Pre Gish/Gish box set has been announced… and a Gish Tour?!… I like when bands put out updated and expanded versions of their albums, or commemorative versions etc, because I think they’re great gifts to the fans. I like all the additional features, it’s like a behind the scenes look at what was going on whether it was demo takes, additional tracks or whatever.
boldensghost:
The oceans of insincerity keep getting deeper and deeper with Billy Corgan and his infinite EGO. Apparently he is doing a “Gish” box set, which frankly while being one of my top ten albums, I’m having a very hard time mustering up even a grunt of displeasure of that news. I’m curious but I don’t know if I’ll buy it, to tell you the truth. The thing that pisses me off about all of this is that I’ve heard that egotistical sack of puss talk about how he doesn’t care about the old stuff or the fans should just get over it. Now he’s putting out a “Gish” box set and he’s going to TOUR the album playing it in it’s entirety. Wow. F-You, Billy Corgan you piece of disingenious crap.